The Pot Roast Melt at Black Bear Diner is a grilled sandwich that combines tender slow-cooked pot roast, grilled onions, melted jack and cheddar cheeses, and horseradish aioli. It’s served between sourdough bread that’s grilled to golden perfection with a garlic-Parmesan crust and comes with a side of savory au jus for dipping.
Think of it as the upgraded cousin of a grilled cheese—with bold flavors and the rich satisfaction of a roast beef dinner.
Why the Pot Roast Melt is a Customer Favorite
Here’s what sets the Black Bear Diner Pot Roast Melt apart from typical diner sandwiches:
Premium slow-cooked beef that’s tender and flavorful
Garlic-Parmesan-crusted sourdough adds crunch and richness
Two types of cheese (jack and cheddar) give it a creamy, melty profile
Horseradish aioli offers a zesty, creamy kick
Served with au jus for added moisture and umami flavor
Black Bear Diner Pot Roast Melt Ingredients
Here’s a complete list of what you’ll find in this flavorful dish:
Slow-Cooked Pot Roast (seasoned and braised beef)
Grilled Onion
Melted Jack Cheese
Melted Cheddar Cheese
Horseradish Aioli
Sourdough Bread
Garlic-Parmesan Crust
Au Jus Dipping Sauce
Allergen Information
Allergen
Contains
Dairy
✅ Yes (cheese, aioli, crust)
Wheat/Gluten
✅ Yes (bread)
Egg
✅ Yes (aioli)
Soy
⚠️ Possible (check aioli/bread)
Tree Nuts
❌ No
Peanuts
❌ No
Shellfish
❌ No
Fish
❌ No
Always inform your server of allergies. Cross-contamination can occur in a shared kitchen.
Nutritional Breakdown
Nutrient
Amount (Est.)
Calories
~1390 kcal
Protein
52g
Total Fat
78g
Saturated Fat
32g
Carbohydrates
95g
Sugars
9g
Sodium
1790mg
Fiber
4g
Cholesterol
160mg
Based on average servings; nutritional content may differ by location and preparation.
Best Customization Tips for the Pot Roast Melt
Want to make this dish uniquely yours? Here’s how to customize it:
Go lighter on the aioli to reduce fat and calories.
Swap cheeses for Swiss or provolone for a different flavor profile.
Add pickles or jalapeños for acidity and a spicy kick.
Request whole wheat or gluten-free bread if available.
Add a side salad instead of fries for a more balanced meal.
FAQs
What comes with the Black Bear Diner Pot Roast Melt?
It typically comes with your choice of side (fries, salad, or veggies) and a serving of au jus for dipping.
Is the pot roast in the melt spicy?
No, the pot roast is seasoned but not spicy. The horseradish aioli adds a mild kick.
Can I get the Pot Roast Melt without cheese?
Yes, you can request the sandwich without jack or cheddar cheese if desired.
Is the sourdough bread toasted?
Yes, the sourdough is grilled with a garlic-Parmesan crust for added flavor and crunch.
What does the horseradish aioli taste like?
It’s a creamy spread with a tangy and slightly spicy flavor, balancing the richness of the meat and cheese.
Is this sandwich available all day?
Availability may vary by location, but most Black Bear Diners serve it during lunch and dinner hours.
Can I order the Pot Roast Melt online?
Yes, Black Bear Diner offers online ordering and pickup through their official website and partner apps.
What drink pairs well with the Pot Roast Melt?
Classic choices include iced tea, root beer, or a milkshake for a nostalgic diner combo.
Is the Pot Roast Melt gluten-free?
No, but you may request a gluten-free bread option where available.
How big is the Pot Roast Melt?
It’s large enough to be a full meal—stacked high with meat and cheese and served with a filling side.
Does Black Bear Diner have a low-calorie version?
Not currently, but you can reduce calories by skipping cheese and aioli or pairing it with a salad.
Is it safe for people with nut allergies?
Yes, this item does not contain peanuts or tree nuts, but always confirm at your location.
Can I get extra au jus?
Yes, you can request an additional serving of au jus for dipping.
Does this sandwich travel well for takeout?
Yes, it’s one of the better Black Bear items for takeout—sturdy bread and meat hold up well.
What’s the best way to reheat the Pot Roast Melt?
Use a toaster oven or skillet to maintain the crispy crust and melty interior.
Final Thoughts
The Black Bear Diner Pot Roast Melt is a masterclass in comfort food, blending savory roast beef, indulgent cheese, and crispy grilled bread into a flavor bomb that’s hard to resist. Whether you’re dining in or ordering to-go, this sandwich delivers big on taste, texture, and satisfaction.
Looking for the best sandwiches at Black Bear Diner? This is it. It’s hearty, satisfying, and completely unforgettable. Perfect for cold days, hungry bellies, or whenever you need a nostalgic comfort food fix.
