If you’re a fan of creamy, fruity desserts that bring both comfort and nostalgia, the Black Bear Diner Banana Cream Pie deserves your full attention. With its smooth banana filling, real banana slices, and a buttery graham cracker crust topped with a fluffy whipped cream crown, this dessert is a must-try for pie lovers of all ages.
In this post, we’ll break down every detail of this classic American dessert, including price, calories, ingredients, nutrition facts, allergens, and frequently asked questions. Whether you’re planning your next diner visit or looking for a decadent dessert to indulge in, this guide will provide all the insights you need.
🥧 What Is the Black Bear Diner Banana Cream Pie?
The Banana Cream Pie at Black Bear Diner is a rich and indulgent dessert featuring:
Silky banana-flavored cream
Fresh banana slices
A buttery graham cracker crust
Topped with real whipped cream
It’s a sweet, creamy, and light option that strikes the perfect balance between tropical flavor and traditional diner comfort.
🧾 Ingredients
Below is a general list of ingredients typically found in a banana cream pie like the one served at Black Bear Diner. Exact ingredient formulations may vary slightly by location.
Here’s a quick glance at the allergens this dessert may contain:
Allergen
Contains
Dairy
✔️ Yes
Eggs
✔️ Yes
Wheat/Gluten
✔️ Yes
Soy
Possibly
Tree Nuts
❌ No
Peanuts
❌ No
Always confirm allergen details at your local diner to ensure safe consumption if you have food sensitivities.
🧬 Nutritional Information (Per Slice)
Nutrient
Amount
Calories
400
Total Fat
22g
Saturated Fat
12g
Cholesterol
70mg
Sodium
190mg
Total Carbohydrates
45g
Dietary Fiber
2g
Sugars
30g
Protein
4g
Pro Tip: This dessert is best enjoyed as an occasional treat, especially after a lighter entrée to balance out the richness.
🍌 Why Banana Cream Pie Is a Customer Favorite
Many Black Bear Diner customers rave about this pie because of its homemade feel, nostalgic flavor, and fresh banana topping. It’s one of those timeless desserts that never go out of style and pairs beautifully with a hot cup of coffee.
🏆 What Makes It Better Than Other Banana Cream Pies?
Following the Skyscraper Technique, here’s how the Black Bear Diner Banana Cream Pie stands out from the competition:
Freshness: Real banana slices instead of banana flavoring alone.
Creaminess: Velvety custard that isn’t too dense or artificial.
Crust Texture: Buttery, crumbly graham cracker base that holds together well.
Generous Portion: One slice is more than enough to satisfy.
No Overpowering Sweetness: Balanced flavor between banana, cream, and crust.
🙋♂️ FAQs
1. What does the Black Bear Diner Banana Cream Pie taste like?
It’s sweet, creamy, and filled with fresh banana flavor, topped with soft whipped cream and a buttery crust.
2. Is the Banana Cream Pie made fresh daily?
Most locations prepare their desserts fresh or receive them regularly from high-quality suppliers. Check with your local diner for specifics.
3. How many calories are in one slice?
Each slice contains 400 calories.
4. Can I get the pie to-go?
Yes, Black Bear Diner offers takeout for most dessert items, including the Banana Cream Pie.
5. Does it contain real bananas?
Absolutely. You’ll find banana slices layered into the cream filling.
6. Is this pie vegetarian?
Yes, it does not contain meat or gelatin, so it’s suitable for a vegetarian diet.
7. Is it gluten-free?
No, the crust contains wheat-based graham crackers, making it unsuitable for gluten-free diets.
8. Is it safe for nut allergies?
There are no tree nuts or peanuts in the pie itself, but cross-contamination is possible in kitchens.
9. Can I order a full Banana Cream Pie?
Some Black Bear Diner locations offer whole pies for special orders. It’s best to call ahead.
10. How much sugar does it contain?
Roughly 30 grams of sugar per slice.
11. Is this pie part of a dessert combo?
Not officially, but you can often pair it with a coffee or drink for a small discount during special promotions.
12. Does it contain eggs?
Yes, as it is a custard-based pie, eggs are typically part of the filling.
13. Can I request modifications?
Limited customization is available, like extra whipped cream or holding the banana slices.
14. How long will it stay fresh if refrigerated?
If kept in a refrigerator, it stays fresh for about 2 to 3 days.
15. Is this a seasonal menu item?
No, the Banana Cream Pie is available year-round at most Black Bear Diner locations.
🍽 Final Thoughts
The Black Bear Diner Banana Cream Pie is more than just a dessert—it’s a delightful experience of nostalgia, comfort, and creamy indulgence. Priced affordably at $7.99, it’s a diner favorite with all the qualities you’d expect from a classic American pie.
With real bananas, a perfect crust, and a balanced sweetness, it’s a must-try whether you’re dining in or grabbing dessert to-go.
