The Black Bear Diner Milkshake is a thick, rich, hand-scooped delight served in a tall glass, often crowned with whipped cream and a cherry. Whether you’re winding down from a hearty meal or simply craving something cold and creamy, this diner classic checks all the boxes. With its retro charm, generous portion size, and nostalgic flavor, it’s no wonder this item is a fan favorite.
Nutrition Facts (Estimated)
Nutrient
Amount per Serving
Calories
520–740
Total Fat
22–38g
Saturated Fat
14–22g
Cholesterol
75–110mg
Sodium
150–280mg
Carbohydrates
60–90g
Sugars
45–65g
Protein
10–15g
Note: Nutritional content varies based on flavor and additional toppings.
Optional additions include sprinkles, cookie crumbs, crushed candies, or peanut butter for customizable flavor experiences.
How to Order the Black Bear Diner Milkshake (Secret Menu Tips)
Ordering the milkshake is simple, but here’s how to level up your experience:
Mix Flavors: Ask for a combo of chocolate + peanut butter or vanilla + strawberry.
Add a Scoop: Some locations may let you add an extra scoop of ice cream.
Customize Toppings: Add crushed Oreos, caramel drizzle, or even a side of bacon for a salty-sweet twist.
Request the Metal Cup: If available, ask to keep the extra metal mixing cup for the full vintage vibe.
Can You Customize the Black Bear Diner Milkshake?
Absolutely! You can:
Choose from classic flavors: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry
Ask for toppings like cherry, caramel, whipped cream
Request mix-ins (at select locations) such as cookie crumbles or nuts
Customizations may vary by location and availability.
FAQs
1. What flavors are available for the Black Bear Diner Milkshake?
Most locations offer vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. Some may have seasonal or specialty flavors.
2. Is the milkshake made with real ice cream?
Yes, Black Bear Diner uses real, hand-scooped ice cream for maximum creaminess and flavor.
3. Can I get my milkshake to-go?
Absolutely. Ask for a to-go cup and lid, though the extra metal cup may not be included.
4. Are refills allowed on milkshakes?
No. Milkshakes are a single-serve item and not refillable.
5. Does the milkshake contain caffeine?
Only if flavored with mocha, coffee, or chocolate, and even then, it’s minimal.
6. Are there vegan milkshake options?
Currently, no vegan milkshakes are listed on the standard menu.
7. Is the milkshake gluten-free?
The base milkshake may be gluten-free, but toppings or flavorings could introduce gluten traces. Always confirm with your server.
8. Can I get a smaller or kids’ size?
Some locations may offer smaller portions or allow milkshakes to be shared with kids.
9. How many calories are in a milkshake?
Between 520 and 740, depending on the flavor and mix-ins.
10. Can I customize toppings?
Yes! Ask for sprinkles, cookies, syrups, or more.
11. Is it safe for nut allergies?
Cross-contamination may occur. Always inform your server if you have nut allergies.
12. What’s the consistency like—thick or thin?
They are generally thick, similar to classic diner shakes, but can be blended thinner upon request.
13. Is whipped cream included automatically?
Yes, unless requested otherwise.
14. Can I split one milkshake between two people?
Sure! It’s often served with an extra cup, making it easy to share.
15. Is it worth the $5.99 price?
Absolutely—for a generous, premium diner-style milkshake, it’s a great value.
Final Thoughts
The Black Bear Diner Milkshake brings back classic American diner nostalgia with every thick, creamy sip. With a $5.99 price tag, it’s an affordable luxury that delivers on both flavor and portion. Whether you enjoy it solo, pair it with a burger, or share it with someone special, this dessert drink remains one of Black Bear Diner’s most indulgent hidden gems.
If you’re searching for an authentic diner milkshake with rich taste, real ingredients, and customizable options, you’ll love what Black Bear Diner has to offer.
